How to Follow Up After a Discovery Call That Didn't Convert (Without Feeling Salesy or Desperate)
You had a discovery call that felt great. Real connection, good conversation, they seemed ready to move forward. You sent the link to sign up and then... crickets. A week goes by. Then two. You tell yourself they must have changed their mind, found someone else, or decided coaching wasn't for them. So you move on.
But here's the thing — you might be completely wrong. And the follow-up you're not doing could be costing you clients.
That said, not every lead is worth chasing. Sometimes the reason they didn't sign up is because they're not actually a good fit — and deep down, you know it. This episode is about how to follow up with intention, how to know when it's worth pursuing, and how to let go when it's not.
This is part three of our five-part series, "The Conversations That Build Coaching Businesses." We're talking about the conversation most coaches skip — and the discernment most coaches don't practice.
In this episode, I cover:
- Why "not right now" feels like rejection (and why it usually isn't about you)
- The gut check: how to know if this person is actually worth following up with
- Questions to ask yourself before you chase a lead — are you excited to work with them, or just chasing revenue?
- What "not right now" actually means — and the difference between "not yet" and "not ever"
- How to respond in the moment when they say "I need to think about it," "The timing isn't right," or "I can't afford it"
- The powerful question that can change everything
- The follow-up that keeps the door open (without being pushy)
- How to stay connected over the long haul with warm leads
- When it's time to let go — and how to do it gracefully
- The mindset shift from rejection to discernment
Series episodes:
- Episode 89: How to Get More Coaching Clients Through Referrals (Without Feeling Salesy)
- Episode 90: How to Network as a Coach (Even If You Hate Networking)
- Episode 92: How to Follow Up After a Discovery Call That Didn't Convert (Without Feeling Salesy or Desperate) ← You are here
- Episode 93: The Price Conversation
- Episode 94: The Difficult Client Conversation
LISTEN TO FULL EPISODE HERE
Resources & Links:
Author & Host
Wendy McCallum
Business Coach for Coaches, Burnout & Alcohol Coach for High Achievers
I’m Wendy McCallum — a coach, mentor, and former lawyer who’s spent the last 15 years helping people build lives and businesses they actually want to wake up to. When I first left law, I had no guidebook for how to do this coaching thing. I floundered — hard. I undercharged, overthought, and overinvested in shiny solutions that didn’t really move the needle. But every mistake taught me something, and eventually, I built the kind of coaching practice I once only dreamed about — one that’s profitable, sustainable, and full of work I truly love. Today, I coach two kinds of people: ✨ Busy professionals who are ready to make big, meaningful changes — whether that's finding balance, recovering from burnout, or rethinking their relationship with alcohol. ✨ And newer coaches who are building their businesses from the ground up and want a clear, sustainable path forward without all the gimmicks and noise. Whether I’m helping someone simplify their business or reclaim their personal life, the heart of my work is the same: giving smart, capable people the clarity, encouragement, and real-world tools they need to move forward — in a way that feels good, not overwhelming. If you’re ready for something better — in your work, your life, or your business — you’re in the right place. And I’m so glad you’re here. IMPORTANT: Blog content including Wendy's podcasts are for information purposes only and not intended in any way to be health advice. Please see full Terms of Use, by clicking on the link in the footer of this page, for details.
Join my List and Grab Your Free Discovery Calls That Convert Template for Coaches!
